Platform Reviews

Payhip vs Gumroad 2026: $273 or $483 on the Same $3,000 Month

November 4, 2026
Share
Payhip vs Gumroad 2026: $273 or $483 on the Same $3,000 Month

Get Creator Revenue Insights

How creators are turning audiences into subscription businesses
Share
On fees alone, Payhip is cheaper than Gumroad at every sales level we tested. Sell $3,000 a month of a $25 product through your own link and Gumroad's fees plus card processing come to $483. Payhip's free plan comes to $273, and its $29 Plus plan comes to $212. Gumroad earns its extra cost only when its marketplace finds buyers you would not have reached yourself. Both platforms sell digital downloads, courses and memberships, and both take care of sales tax for you. The difference is in how each one charges, and that difference grows as you sell more. Key Takeaways:
  • Gumroad charges 10% + $0.50 per direct sale, plus card processing of 2.9% + $0.30, according to its own fees article. Sales through its Discover marketplace pay a flat 30% that includes processing
  • Payhip's pricing page lists three plans with the same features: Free at 5%, Plus at $29 a month and 2%, and Pro at $99 a month and 0%, with Stripe or PayPal charging their standard rates on top
  • On a $25 product, Payhip Plus becomes cheaper than Payhip Free at $967 in monthly sales, and Pro becomes cheaper than Plus at $3,500. Both thresholds hold whatever your product costs
  • Gumroad's fixed $0.50 hurts small payments most. Two hundred members at $5 a month cost $289 in fees on Gumroad and $139 on Payhip Free
  • Gumroad cuts its rate to 5% + $0.50 for the rest of a calendar month once your sales pass $20,000. Even then, a $25,000 month costs $3,775 on Gumroad and $1,124 on Payhip Pro
Every figure below comes from the platforms' own pages, checked on November 4, 2026. Card processing uses Stripe's standard US rate of 2.9% + $0.30. Stripe adds 1.5% for cards issued outside your country, and that surcharge applies the same way on both platforms.
GumroadPayhip FreePayhip PlusPayhip Pro
Monthly fee$0$0$29$99
Platform fee per direct sale10% + $0.505%2%0%
Card processing2.9% + $0.30 on topStripe or PayPal standard rateStripe or PayPal standard rateStripe or PayPal standard rate
Marketplace sales30%, processing includedNo marketplace rate listedNo marketplace rate listedNo marketplace rate listed
Volume discount5% + $0.50 after $20,000 in a monthNoneNoneNone
Sales tax handledYes, all tax obligations since January 1, 2025EU/UK VAT, US and Canadian sales taxSameSame
When you get paidWeekly by default, $100 minimum, 7-day holdDeposited to your Stripe or PayPal at the saleSameSame
The table shows where each platform makes its money. Gumroad has no monthly fee and charges more on every sale. Payhip lets you pay a monthly fee to lower the cut on each sale. Which one costs less depends on how much you sell. Gumroad charges 10% plus $0.50 on each sale made through your profile or your own links. Card processing of 2.9% plus $0.30 is charged on top. Sales that come through its Discover marketplace pay a flat 30% instead, with processing included.
Gumroad's help-center article on its fees: 10% + $0.50 per transaction excluding credit card processing at 2.9% + $0.30, a flat 30% on marketplace sales, and the high-volume discount to 5% + $0.50 once paid sales in a calendar month reach $20,000
Gumroad's pricing page shows "10% + $0.50" in large type. Its help center adds the line that changes the math: the rate "does not include" card processing. A $25 sale therefore costs $2.50 + $0.50 + $0.73 + $0.30, or $4.03. That is 16.1% of the price. The same article describes two details that are easy to miss.
  • The high-volume discount resets every month. Once your paid sales in a calendar month reach $20,000, new direct sales that month pay 5% + $0.50. The rate goes back to 10% on the 1st, and a refund that drops you below $20,000 brings back the higher rate until you pass the line again.
  • Gumroad returns its own fee on a refund. The processing portion is kept. If refunds are a real cost for your product, our guide to creator refunds and chargebacks compares how other platforms handle them.
Gumroad also became responsible for its sellers' sales tax on January 1, 2025, according to its pricing page. That takes real work off a small creator. Our full Gumroad review covers the rest of the product. Payhip has three plans, and they include the same features. Free charges 5% per sale, Plus costs $29 a month and charges 2%, and Pro costs $99 a month and charges no Payhip fee at all. Stripe or PayPal charge their standard rates on every plan. Because every plan includes every feature, the plan you pick is purely a fee decision. You are not giving up any tools by staying on Free. Payhip also takes on sales tax. Its tax page says it acts "as your reseller" for digital EU and UK VAT, and that as a marketplace facilitator in the US and a digital platform operator in Canada, "we're responsible for collecting and paying sales tax here and not you." Payhip's pricing page also says sales are deposited "immediately after a transaction has been completed," because the money goes through your own Stripe or PayPal account. There is one limit for memberships. Payhip's recurring payments guide says recurring billing works only for bundles, memberships, courses and coaching, and only when Stripe is your payment processor. It also says a customer "will immediately lose access the moment they cancel." Here is the same $25 digital product at four sales levels. All sales are direct, all buyers pay by US card, and every column includes processing. The number in each cell is the total you pay in fees for the month.
Monthly sales ($25 product)GumroadPayhip FreePayhip PlusPayhip Pro
$1,000 (40 sales)$161$91$90$140
$3,000 (120 sales)$483$273$212$222
$10,000 (400 sales)$1,610$910$639$509
$25,000 (1,000 sales)$3,775$2,275$1,554$1,124
Line chart of monthly fees on a $25 product from $0 to $6,000 in sales: Gumroad rises steepest to about $966, Payhip Free to $546, Plus to $395 and Pro to $345, with Plus overtaking Free at $967 and Pro overtaking Plus at $3,500, and labeled points at $3,000 showing Gumroad $483, Free $273, Plus $212 and Pro $222
The two Payhip thresholds do not depend on your price. Moving from Free to Plus saves 3% of sales and costs $29, so it pays off once you sell more than $967 a month. Moving from Plus to Pro saves another 2% and costs $70 more, so it pays off above $3,500 a month. The $25 example only sets how many sales it takes to get there. Gumroad's volume discount narrows the gap at $25,000, but does not close it. The first $20,000 still pays the full 10% + $0.50, and the $0.50 stays on every sale after that. These are fee totals, not profit. Our gross margin explainer shows how to turn them into the share of each sale you actually keep.
See What We’d Build You →
A percentage fee shrinks along with the price. A fixed fee does not. Gumroad charges $0.50 per sale, plus $0.30 for processing, whatever the price, so the cheaper the sale, the larger the share those fixed fees take. A Black Friday discount. Take the $25 product at 30% off, so it sells for $17.50. Gumroad's fees come to $3.06, or 17.5% of the sale. On Payhip Free they come to $1.68, or 9.6%. The discount costs you 30% of the price, and on Gumroad the fixed fees take a bigger share of what is left. If you are planning a holiday sale, our guide to Black Friday membership discounts covers the separate question of what happens when a discounted plan renews. A $5 monthly membership. Two hundred members paying $5 bring in $1,000 a month. Each renewal on Gumroad costs $0.50 + $0.50 + $0.15 + $0.30, or $1.45, so the month costs $289 in fees, almost 29% of revenue. Payhip Free costs $139 and Plus costs $138. Every renewal pays this cost again, so the gap repeats every month. Both platforms collect and pay sales tax for you, which used to be the strongest reason to choose Gumroad. Neither is now the simpler choice on tax. The real difference is when you get paid. Gumroad keeps sales in your Gumroad balance and pays them out on a schedule. Its payout guide lists a $100 minimum balance and a 7-day hold before a sale is eligible on the weekly, monthly and quarterly schedules. Daily payouts are available to US sellers with eligible bank accounts after four earlier payouts. Payhip's money moves through your own Stripe or PayPal account at the time of the sale, and Stripe then pays out to your bank on its own schedule. If a few days of cash flow matter to you, our comparison of how fast creator platforms pay covers six more. Gumroad is worth paying for when its Discover marketplace brings you buyers who would never have found your link. A $25 marketplace sale costs $7.50 and leaves you $17.50. A direct sale on Gumroad leaves you $20.98. On Payhip Free it leaves $22.73. Payhip's pricing page lists no marketplace rate; its plans price the sales made through your own store. So the question is where your buyers come from. A creator with a large audience sends most buyers from their own channels, and a marketplace adds little for them. A creator with a small audience and a product people search for, such as templates, presets or a niche tool, may find that Discover sales are worth 30%. They would not have made those sales at all. Switching costs matter too. If your customer list, memberships and links already run on Gumroad, moving means migrating subscribers and updating every link. Our Lemon Squeezy review has five checks to run before any storefront switch.
  • Selling under about $1,000 a month through your own links: Payhip Free. There is no monthly fee and it charges half Gumroad's percentage with no extra $0.50
  • Selling $1,000 to $3,500 a month: Payhip Plus
  • Selling more than $3,500 a month: Payhip Pro. At $10,000 a month it saves about $1,100 compared with Gumroad
  • Relying on marketplace discovery, or already set up on Gumroad with many members: Gumroad, if Discover is actually bringing you sales. Check your sales export, which shows the fee on every sale
  • Selling low-priced memberships: Payhip, with Stripe connected, because of the fixed per-sale fee
A storefront sells the file. It does not give your audience a reason to come back the next day. A creator whose audience pays every month for something they use, such as a tracker, a daily practice or a workout plan, is running a different business from one selling downloads. That is the business Built by Foundry builds and runs with creators, and our app care team keeps those products working after launch.
See What We’d Build You →
Yes, for direct sales. On a $25 product, Payhip's free plan costs $2.28 per sale including card processing, and Gumroad costs $4.03. Payhip's paid plans cost even less once your monthly sales pass $967 (Plus) and $3,500 (Pro). No. Gumroad's help center says its 10% + $0.50 "does not include" credit card processing of 2.9% + $0.30 or PayPal fees. Only marketplace sales, at 30%, include processing. Payhip itself does not, but the processors do. Its pricing page says PayPal and Stripe "will still charge at their standard rates" on every plan, including Pro. Both do. Gumroad says it has handled all of its sellers' tax obligations since January 1, 2025. Payhip says it is responsible for digital EU and UK VAT and, as a marketplace facilitator, for US and Canadian sales tax. Yes, with Stripe connected. Payhip limits recurring billing to bundles, memberships, courses and coaching, offers weekly, monthly, quarterly or annual billing, and ends a member's access the moment they cancel.
Our work

Creators who already did this

These are apps we designed, built, shipped, and still run today, with the creator keeping the code and the audience.

Brandon Whiteleather

Brandon Whiteleather

Founder & CEO of Freeze Dry Buddy

Freeze drying made foolproof, from a homesteader who's done it 1,000 times.

Top Food App1.4M+ followers
Read the case study
Kristen Donathan

Kristen Donathan

Founder & CEO of Stain Fix

Snap a stain. Get the fix in seconds.

Top Lifestyle App1.5M+ followers
Read the case study
Stain Fix screenshots
Ellie Fausett

Ellie Fausett

Founder & CEO of Vector Guard

Spot disease-carrying pests before they reach your family.

Top Health App
Read the case study
Vector Guard screenshots

Creator app strategy

Curious what your app could be?

Enter your handle and BUILT BY FOUNDRY will research your audience and present custom app concepts. Free.

Payhip vs Gumroad 2026: $273 or $483 on the Same $3,000 Month