MKBHD Panels App: Why 20M Subscribers Were Not Enough

In September 2024, Marques Brownlee launched Panels, a curated wallpaper app. Within days, it hit #1 in the Photos category on both the App Store and Google Play. Fifteen months later, he shut it down. The app made $95,000 total from 900,000 downloads. MKBHD's estimated net worth is $15-20 million. Panels was a rounding error—but the lessons matter.

The Launch

MKBHD announced Panels during his iPhone 16 review, one of his most-watched videos of the year. Massive audience, high engagement, built-in distribution. The timing looked perfect. The app offered curated wallpapers from digital artists, with revenue split going to creators. The concept wasn't bad. The execution was. The pricing: $49.99 per year or $11.99 per month. For wallpapers. The free tier: Lower-quality images locked behind ads. Users had to watch multiple ads to download a single wallpaper. The data collection: The App Store privacy label showed Panels tracking location, usage data, and personal identifiers—more than a wallpaper app needs. The backlash came fast.

The Criticism Hit Different

MKBHD built his reputation on honest tech reviews. He's called out companies for bad products, questionable pricing, and privacy overreach. His review of the Humane AI Pin was so harsh it sparked debates about whether critics have too much power. Now his own app was getting the same treatment. "If I was reviewing this app, I would not have been very nice," Brownlee admitted in a follow-up video. The irony wasn't lost on anyone. Comments pointed out the contradiction: the reviewer who told people never to buy products based on "promise of future updates" was now asking users to trust that Panels would get better over time.

What MKBHD Did Right

Brownlee responded quickly and transparently. Within 48 hours of launch, he acknowledged the problems publicly. "We failed on the price front," he said. No excuses, no deflection. The fixes came fast:

Price dropped to $2/month (from $12)
Removed intrusive ads from the wallpaper feed
Fixed privacy permissions to only request what was necessary
Committed to weekly content drops every Friday

The response was textbook crisis management. Sentiment analysis of YouTube comments showed a shift after the updates—words like "respect," "accountability," and "transparency" replaced the initial anger. But it wasn't enough.

Our work

How Ellie Fausett Turned Her Public-Health Research Into the Vector Guard App

Epidemiologist Ellie Fausett and BUILT BY FOUNDRY turned years of field research into Vector Guard, an iOS app for identifying ticks and mosquitoes and staying safe outdoors.

Read the case study → (opens in a new tab)

Why It Still Failed

Here's the uncomfortable truth: MKBHD did almost everything right after launch. He listened. He adapted. He was transparent. And it still didn't matter. The numbers:

900,000 lifetime downloads (impressive for most apps, modest for 20M subscribers)
$95,000 total revenue (~$0.11 per download)
Final month: 3,000 downloads, $500 revenue

The app couldn't sustain. By November 2025, it had fallen off the US app store charts entirely. On December 1st, Brownlee announced the shutdown. "We knew it was niche, but we made mistakes in making our first app, and ultimately, we weren't able to turn it into the vision I had."

Lessons for Creators

Panels failed not because MKBHD made an app, but because of which app he made and how he launched it.

Audience ≠ Product-Market Fit

Twenty million subscribers is distribution, not validation. MKBHD's audience watches tech reviews—they didn't necessarily want to pay monthly for wallpapers. The product needs to match what your audience actually wants to buy, not just what you want to sell.

First Impressions Are (Almost) Everything

Panels launched broken. The pricing was wrong, the ads were intrusive, the privacy was questionable. Even though MKBHD fixed everything within weeks, the narrative was set. "MKBHD's app is a cash grab" became the story, and no amount of updates could undo it. Compare this to Focus Friend (Hank Green's app) or Sweat (Kayla Itsines' app)—both launched with clear value and fair pricing from day one.

Subscription Fatigue Is Real

Users are exhausted by subscriptions. Paying $2/month for wallpapers—even good ones—feels like another recurring charge in an endless list. The value proposition wasn't strong enough. Fitness apps work because ongoing guidance has clear value. Productivity tools work because daily use justifies the cost. Wallpapers are a "set and forget" product sold with a "pay forever" model. The mismatch killed it.

Niche Products Need Niche Economics

Panels required a full development team, artist partnerships, content curation, and ongoing maintenance. That's expensive infrastructure for a product with a tiny addressable market. The unit economics never worked.

Want to avoid these mistakes?

We build apps with sustainable business models—and we don't launch until the fundamentals are right.

See What We’d Build You →

The Graceful Exit

How MKBHD ended Panels says a lot about him. He announced the shutdown in an unlisted YouTube video—available to anyone who wanted it, but not pushed to his main feed. No dramatic farewell, no playing victim. The details were thoughtful:

Full refunds for annual subscribers (prorated)
All user data deleted after shutdown
Code open-sourced on GitHub under Apache 2.0 license

That last part is notable. Most failed apps just disappear. MKBHD is letting developers build on what he started.

Live every Thursday

Watch us tear down a creator business, live

Every Thursday at 11 AM PT we take a real creator business and show the app hiding inside it: the wedge, the paid loop, the pricing, and what would sink it. Free, and the replay goes to everyone who registers.

Save your seat → (opens in a new tab)

What This Means for Creators

Panels is a cautionary tale, but it's not an argument against creators building apps. It's an argument for building the right apps the right way. What Panels got wrong:

Product didn't match audience needs
Launched before it was ready
Wrong business model for the product category
Priced for maximum extraction, not maximum adoption

What successful creator apps get right:

Solve a real problem the creator's audience has
Launch with a compelling free tier or fair pricing
Match the business model to usage patterns
Test with real users before public launch

MKBHD has 20 million subscribers, a $15-20 million net worth, and a team of developers. He still couldn't make a wallpaper app work. But Kayla Itsines built a $400 million fitness app. Hank Green built a productivity app that hit #1 and stayed there. Jeff Nippard became a co-owner of a $30 million nutrition app. The difference isn't audience size. It's product-market fit, pricing, and execution.

The Takeaway

MKBHD's Panels app failed publicly and expensively. But Brownlee handled it with more grace than most founders handle success. He admitted mistakes, tried to fix them, and when it didn't work, he shut down cleanly and open-sourced the code. That's not a failure of character. It's a failure of strategy—one that every creator thinking about building an app should study. The lesson isn't "don't build apps." It's "build the right app, price it fairly, and launch it ready."

Thinking about building an app? We help creators avoid the Panels pitfalls—3-week delivery, and we don't launch until it's right.