Bella Coco Has 1.94M Subscribers and 3 App Ratings. The Top Crochet App Has 32,542

Key Takeaways:

Bella Coco Crochet showed 1.94M subscribers on September 16, 2026, and her Instagram showed 289K followers across 1,416 posts. Sarah-Jayne Fragola has been teaching crochet since 2011 and passed a million subscribers by May 2022, when she opened a studio and hired three people
Her storefront returned 105 products and 106 priced variants on September 16, 2026, from £1.69 to £139.00. Ninety-four of the 105 are PDF crochet patterns, priced £1.69 to £19.79, at a median of £4.03
She already built the recurring product. The Crochet Community sells at £14 a month or £139 a year, and it has its own iPhone app under her own company
That app is free, sits in Education, holds 3 US ratings at 3.7 stars, and was released May 16, 2024. Its listing has no In-App Purchases row and carries an adult age rating: 17+ in Apple's lookup response, shown as 18+ Years on the store page. Its own description calls it a tool "for existing members"
A US App Store search for "crochet" on September 16, 2026 returned YarnPal at 32,542 ratings and Loopsy at 15,625, published by Singapore's PIXELCELL PTE. LIMITED and by Springtown Labs Inc. Her app was not in the first 30 results
It does rank first for "crochet community" and first for "bella coco". She owns her own name on the shelf and nothing else on it

Sarah-Jayne Fragola has already done the thing this blog usually spends a whole post asking creators to do. She built the subscription. It is not a course sold twice or a Patreon tier bolted onto a channel. The Crochet Community charges £14 a month or £139 a year, it has a pattern library, a stitch library, live events and a social area, and it ships as a real iPhone app on a developer account that says Bella Coco Ltd. Most creators with two million subscribers never get that far. So this post is not about a missing product. It is about which side of the door the product is on.

What Does Bella Coco Actually Sell?

Mostly £4 PDFs. On September 16, 2026 her storefront returned 105 products across 106 priced variants, from £1.69 to £139.00. Ninety-four of those 105 are PDF crochet patterns, priced between £1.69 and £19.79 at a median of £4.03. The rest are two books, a stitch card deck, a keychain, a pin, and the gift memberships. Read that catalog as a business rather than as a shop. Ninety-four items that a customer buys once, downloads, and never returns for. The top of the price list is not a product at all: it is £139.00 for a twelve month gift membership, which is the subscription wearing a bow. She is not undercharging out of nerves. A crochet pattern is worth roughly £4, and 1.94 million subscribers make £4 a respectable number. The problem is the shape. A pattern is a transaction. The person who buys one has no reason to be back on Tuesday, and the money resets every month. Which she clearly knows, because she fixed it. The membership is the fix.

Why Does Her App Have 3 Ratings?

Because it was built for people who already subscribed. The Crochet Community app is free, sits in the Education category, holds 3 US ratings at a 3.7 average, and was released on May 16, 2024. Its listing has no In-App Purchases row, so nobody can subscribe inside it. Its description opens with "Your membership content at your fingertips" and calls it "the dedicated app for existing members of The Crochet Community." That is an honest description of a members' clubhouse. It is also a perfect description of a product the App Store cannot sell.

Apple's whole machine runs on a download that turns into a paying customer inside the app. No purchase row means no trial, no paywall, no price, and nothing for the algorithm to rank against the apps that do have those things. A search result that cannot convert is a search result Apple has no reason to show. So it does not show it. Search "crochet" in the US store today and the first 30 results do not include her. Search "crochet community" or "bella coco" and she is number one, because those are the queries typed by people who already know her name and already pay her.

Who Owns the Crochet Shelf?

Developers you have never heard of, in countries she does not live in, who between them hold more than sixty thousand US ratings on a craft she taught the internet.

App	Publisher	US ratings	Released
YarnPal	PIXELCELL PTE. LIMITED	32,542	December 19, 2024
Loopsy	Springtown Labs Inc.	15,625	May 23, 2025
LoopCraft	Scala technology limited	5,213	October 21, 2025
kntd:discover	Samuel Harrison	5,189	August 10, 2021
My Row Counter	AnnapurnApp Technologies UG	3,686	February 1, 2018
The Crochet Community	Bella Coco Ltd	3	May 16, 2024

Look at the dates. Her app shipped first. YarnPal launched seven months after it and Loopsy a year after it, and both are now measured in five figures while hers is measured in single digits. Neither of them taught anybody to crochet. They shipped a row counter, a yarn stash and a pattern importer, put a price inside the app, and let the store do the rest. This blog keeps finding the same structure in different crafts. In barbecue, the thermometer manufacturer holds 141,153 ratings to the pitmaster's 2,065. In gardening, a creator with 1,060 products filed his app under Shopping. In nursing, a teacher with 842K subscribers ended up at 26 ratings. Crochet is the version where the creator built the subscription, built the app, and still pointed both of them at the people who were already inside.

The audience is on the shelf. The product should be too.

BUILT BY FOUNDRY builds the subscription product your audience already needs, prices it with you, and runs it forever. $0 upfront, revenue share, roughly three weeks to the App Store.

See What We’d Build You →

Why Does a Crochet App Carry an 18+ Age Rating?

Because it contains a social area, and the membership terms require members to be 18 or over with age verification for that area. Apple's lookup response returns a 17+ content advisory for The Crochet Community, and the US store page displays it as 18+ Years. YarnPal and Loopsy are both rated 4+.

That rating is a rational answer to a real moderation question, and it is also a wall in front of a craft that a lot of people learn at thirteen. Age rating is not decoration: it decides who the store will show an app to, and the rules behind those brackets got stricter, not looser, in 2026. A community feature dragged the whole product into an adult bracket, on a listing that could not sell anything anyway. Two decisions, one consequence. The social area set the age gate. The missing purchase row removed the reason for the store to rank it. Between them they turned a genuine subscription business into an invisible one.

The Door Test

Here is the one-line version you can run against your own product in about a minute. If a stranger downloaded your app right now, could they become a paying customer without ever leaving it? If the answer is no, you did not build a product on the App Store. You built a door, and a door only works for people already holding a key. Doors are useful. A member who wants her pattern library on the bus is genuinely better served by an app than by a browser tab. But a door does not acquire anybody, it does not rank, and it will never introduce your work to someone who has not heard of you. The test has a second half that matters more. Could a stranger who has never heard of you find that app by searching for the craft, not for you? Sarah-Jayne fails that one by 32,542 ratings, and she fails it while being, by a wide margin, the most trusted teacher in her category.

If You Teach a Craft

If you are a creator whose audience makes something with their hands, read the numbers above as a warning rather than as a story about somebody else. Yarn, wood, clay, bread, bikes, cameras, plants: every one of those categories has a top app, every one of those apps is free with a price inside it, and almost none of them belong to the person who taught the category how to do the thing. What Sarah-Jayne has that PIXELCELL does not is the part nobody can buy. She has 1.94 million subscribers who learned to hold a hook from her, fifteen years of tutorials, a pattern library, a stitch library, a working £14 a month membership, and a community that already calls itself a community. What she does not have is a listing a beginner in Ohio can find on the day she buys her first ball of yarn, download for free, use immediately, and pay for a week later without ever hearing the words Bella Coco first. That is not a bigger product. It is the same product with the paywall on the inside and the front door on the shelf. The pattern library becomes the free surface, the counters and the project journal become the daily reason to open it, the membership becomes the subscription Apple knows how to sell, and the store starts doing customer acquisition for a business that currently does all of its own. Built by Foundry builds that product, prices it with the creator, ships it in roughly three weeks, and runs it forever afterwards so the creator never becomes a software company by accident. $0 upfront, revenue share, and the creator owns the business. That is the whole model. Sarah-Jayne Fragola built the subscription that most creators never build. It is sitting behind a door, on a shelf owned by strangers, in a category she taught.

See What We’d Build You →

All figures verified September 16, 2026 against the Bella Coco YouTube and Instagram profiles, the bellacococrochet.com product endpoint, The Crochet Community membership join page, Apple's US App Store listings and search results for "crochet", "crochet community" and "bella coco", and the May 2022 Tubefilter interview linked above. Current-state claims require revalidation before later use.

Bella Coco Has 1.94M Subscribers and 3 App Ratings. The Top Crochet App Has 32,542

Get Creator Revenue Insights

What Does Bella Coco Actually Sell?

Why Does Her App Have 3 Ratings?

Who Owns the Crochet Shelf?

Why Does a Crochet App Carry an 18+ Age Rating?

The Door Test

If You Teach a Craft

Creators who already did this

Liv Merima

Brandon Whiteleather

Kristen Donathan

Curious what your app could be?

Keep reading